Declan O’Brien

Self-Help for Real Life

Settling an Estate

Do You Need a Lawyer to Settle an Estate? A Plain-English Way to Decide

Probably, for part of it. Possibly not, for all of it. Here is the short test, what a probate lawyer actually does, and the questions to ask at the first meeting.

It is one of the first questions a new executor asks, usually at about two in the morning, and the honest answer is: probably, for part of it; possibly not, for all of it. The estate pays the fee, not you, which takes some of the sting out. But a lawyer is not required by law in most situations, and plenty of simple estates are settled without one. Here is how to decide.

You can likely handle it yourself if

The estate is small enough to qualify for your state’s simplified procedure (every state has one, with its own dollar threshold), or the assets that actually pass through probate are a bank account, a car, and household goods with no real estate; and the will is clear; and the family agrees; and you have the time and the temperament for forms.

Many county probate courts have a self-help desk, a packet of forms, and clerks who, while they cannot give legal advice, are very good at telling you which form comes next. Legal aid offices and law school clinics help with small estates in many areas. If that describes your situation, start there before you hire anyone.

You almost certainly want a lawyer if

You also want one if the thought of the court filings makes you feel sick. That feeling does not improve, and the fee comes out of the estate.

What a probate lawyer does, and does not do

They prepare and file the court documents, advise you at each fork, handle the creditor notices, and prepare the final accounting. They do not find the assets, sort the house, call the pension office, or keep your records. That is your job, and the better you do it, the less the lawyer costs, because you are paying for their hours.

What it costs

This varies by state and by lawyer. Some charge by the hour, in which case an organized executor saves real money. Some charge a flat fee for a routine estate. A few states allow a fee set by statute as a percentage of the estate, which can be expensive for a large, simple estate and is often negotiable. Ask at the first meeting: how do you charge, what is a typical total for an estate like this one, and what will make it cost more. Write the answers down.

How to find one

Start with the lawyer who drew up the will, if there was one; they know the document and may have the file. If not, the state or county bar association runs a referral service, and “probate” or “estate administration” is the specialty you are asking for. Ask friends who have done this. Avoid any lawyer who will not quote a fee structure, who cannot explain probate in plain words, or who tells you the estate is sure to take years. Meet two if you can. You will be working with this person for the better part of a year.

The first meeting

Bring the will, a death certificate, and whatever paperwork you have gathered. Leave with four things: whether probate is needed and which kind; the first filing and what they need from you for it; their fee; and the next three things to do. Many probate lawyers do not charge for a first consultation, and more than one has told a new executor, after an hour, that they did not need a lawyer at all.

The accountant is a separate question

If the person filed their own simple taxes, a tax preparer may be able to help with the final return. If the estate will earn income during the process, interest, dividends, rent, the sale of a house, it may need its own tax return, and that is the point at which an accountant who handles estates earns their fee. Ask the lawyer for a name.

In short: small and simple, try the clerk’s self-help desk. House, business, conflict, or complexity, hire a probate lawyer, interview two, ask how they charge, and do the organizing yourself to keep the bill down. The estate pays.

You’re the Executor Now

A plain-English checklist and workbook for settling a loved one’s estate: the first two weeks, probate explained, whether you need a lawyer, the exact words for every call, and nine fill-in worksheets. Large-print paperback and Kindle.

View on Amazon ›

This article is general information, not legal advice. Probate rules, deadlines, and the order in which debts are paid differ by state. Where this article and your attorney, your probate clerk, or your state’s forms disagree, they are right.